SmallBizGenius Analysis
Shutterfly receives generally positive reviews for its personalized photo products and responsive customer service. However, some customers report issues with a recent software update and occasional shipping problems.
Category Breakdown
Scores based on analysis of 284 recent reviews
Customer Service
8.5/10Many reviewers praise Shutterfly's customer service for being responsive, helpful, and willing to resolve issues quickly. Customers report receiving replacements or refunds without much hassle when products are defective or lost in transit, as one reviewer noted, "You went above and beyond! My issue wasn't really with your company...you still sent out another product and refunded me."
30 reviews mention thisProduct Quality
7.8/10A large number of reviewers are happy with the quality of Shutterfly's products, including photo books, calendars, and cards. They often mention the vibrant colors and durable materials. One reviewer stated, "I love your products, I have so much fun making photo books for family and friends."
25 reviews mention thisShipping and Delivery
6.5/10While some reviewers praise Shutterfly's quick and reliable shipping, others report issues with delayed or lost orders. Several customers mention problems with specific shipping carriers, like Mail Innovations. One reviewer said, "The order never arrived. Please stop shipping via Mail Innovations."
20 reviews mention thisWebsite Experience/Software Update
4.0/10A significant number of recent reviews express strong dissatisfaction with Shutterfly's 2026 software update. Customers describe the new editor as clunky, difficult to use, and lacking essential features. One reviewer lamented, "Shutterfly used to be easy and fun and now it's unusable."
22 reviews mention thisEase of Use
7.0/10Many customers found the website easy to use prior to the update, while others, especially those new to the platform, found it cumbersome even before the update. The recent update has exacerbated these issues for many long-time users. One reviewer mentioned, "The Shutterfly website is friendly and easy to use. Ordering was easy.", while another said, "It was quite difficult to use the tools."
10 reviews mention thisPros & Cons
What Customers Love
"I was very impressed by Shutterfly's customer service...the service agent said 'we will send you another one free of charge.'"
"I have done many photo books with Shutterfly. They do a quality product..."
"Very easy and effective way to make calendars. Improves every year."
"Shipping was super fast and I was able to use a discount coupon for a great price."
"Shutterfly is my go to for anything photo related. A+ on all accounts."
Common Complaints
"The new editor is terrible, not intuitive, and lacks advanced editing."
"The order never arrived. Please stop shipping via Mail Innovations."
"I called about a defect in a product I had ordered."
"I ordered 213 prints...and 80 (plus) of them arrived completely unusable—heads, faces, and limbs are all chopped off due to terrible auto-cropping."
"I always write on my calendars, but pencil cannot be erased. A huge smudge mark is left behind."
Common Questions About Shutterfly
Answers derived from customer review patterns
Is Shutterfly legit and trustworthy?
Yes, Shutterfly is a legitimate company that has been providing personalized photo products for many years. The majority of customers report positive experiences with the quality of the products and the responsiveness of customer service. While some customers have experienced issues with shipping or product defects, Shutterfly generally addresses these concerns by offering replacements or refunds. However, potential users should be aware of the recent software update, which has received negative feedback from some users.
Based on 45 reviewsDoes Shutterfly have good customer service?
Yes, many reviewers praise Shutterfly's customer service for being helpful and responsive. Customers report that customer service representatives are quick to address issues, such as product defects or shipping delays, and often offer solutions like free replacements or refunds. One reviewer shared, "Customer service was unbelievable...they replaced it without any question!"
Based on 30 reviewsIs Shutterfly worth it for small business?
Shutterfly can be a worthwhile option for small businesses looking to create personalized marketing materials, client gifts, or internal resources. The platform offers a wide range of customizable products and generally delivers high-quality results. However, small business owners should be aware of potential design challenges with the new software update and factor in potential shipping delays when planning projects.
Based on 25 reviewsWhat is Shutterfly's return policy like?
While the specific details of Shutterfly's official return policy are not explicitly mentioned in these reviews, the general consensus is that Shutterfly is accommodating when issues arise. Customers report receiving replacements or refunds for defective products or lost shipments without significant difficulty. This suggests a customer-friendly approach to returns and issue resolution.
Based on 15 reviewsHow has the recent Shutterfly software update affected user experience?
The recent Shutterfly software update has had a largely negative impact on user experience, according to a significant number of reviewers. Many customers describe the new editor as clunky, difficult to use, and less intuitive than the previous version. Some users report that basic editing tasks are now more time-consuming and frustrating, leading to dissatisfaction with the overall design process.
Based on 22 reviewsLooking for Something Different?
Compare Shutterfly against 25 similar office & equipment options.
View Alternatives